This argument will continue for eons. However, whether a boat ties up or anchors, it is a better technique to handle everything from the cockpit without risking anyone on the bow deck.
When we head offshore for an overnighter, we always rig our "tag line." We have a 5/8" tweisted nylon line with 12" eye splices in ecah end. We have a couple of them. They are long enough to reach from the bow cleat to the port side tower leg with enough extra to be able to tie the end to the tower leg when running.
We tie the "tag line" off to the bow cleat with one spliced eye.
Everything is then handled from the cockpit tying the anchor line and a retrieve line, 1/2" polypro, to the other eye splice with heavy duty carabiner screw-together clips. When the anchor goes overboard from the cockpit, we turn the boat 30 to 45 degrees and back away from the line leaving plenty of room. We carry 2200' of 1/2" nylon. There are 3 600' shots each with 4' eye splices in each end large enough to do a loop to loop by putting the whole fish tote holding the next 600' through the eye. The final 400' is 3/4" that we use for inshore anchoring or for emergencies. It has large eye splices too.
Once the anchor is set, the "tag line" runs from the bow cleat to the "junction" of the anchor line, the retrieve line, and the "tag line." There are times when we use an anchor release at that location. If we do, we hook a ball to the junction so we can retrieve the anchor line later if we need to pop off.
The anchor is retrieved using an anchor ball, the best contraption ever invented.
In any case, everything offshore is done from the cockpit. It is far safer than working on the bow deck even if you have a bow rail.
Capt. Lindsay Fuller
June Bug Charters
Beach Haven, NJ
609-685-2839
http://www.Fish-JuneBug.com