Killing Fish in Tournaments - Page 2

marlinrojo · 08-07-2009, 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fritz

Guys sticking a gaff in a Whte during a tournament and then throwing it back overboard when it doesn't measure. What ever happened to billing a fish?

sounds like tag and release to me

Bert Rodgers · 08-07-2009, 02:06 PM

Well said JP.

Marlinrojo , not so much.

Bert

reel fool · 08-07-2009, 06:08 PM

You guys poo pooing on killing marlin have obviously never eaten blue marlin...its excellent.

Tastes just like bald eagle....and way better than spotted owl.

LongRigger · 08-07-2009, 09:35 PM

I prefer tiger jerky with a side of bottlenose dolphin.

BigSteads · 08-07-2009, 10:30 PM

I think people jump to alot on conclusions about 'under sized' fish way too fast, they made fed. length, and tournament length so...you grease em, all the whites on the board all were withing 69 3/4'' to 73.5'' your talking numbers where only judgement comes into play and it is really easy to sit behind a computer at home and point the finger, when your staring at the fish laying on the deck its a whole different ballgame. Dont give me the bullsh*t caclulations either on a whitey.

Blues, yea...let me haul it on board do all the measurements to the T calc it, and throw it back. Pretty sure it may swim off the first 100 feet. so to me, weigh it, give to charity and people who need something to eat.

19 dead whitey

7?? blues.

top 2/3 fish biggest in 29 years? on whites
1st place blue biggest ever. period.
Sounds like good numbers to me over the hundreds that were released, +/- 7% of the fish hooked this year were greased.

congrats to all who weighed fish, and Longfin Lance on taking 2nd!

ps. how about the rest of the leaderboard this year

Zummie · 08-07-2009, 11:09 PM

Come on now, anyone can kill a fish. Club a kitten and throw it on the barbie with a little mango chutney. Now, that's good eating.

joeksr · 08-07-2009, 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zummie

Come on now, anyone can kill a fish. Club a kitten and throw it on the barbie with a little mango chutney. Now, that's good eating.

Damn bro. A legal Tuna tastes better than Kitten
And,
Everybody knows Veal is better than cow.

.
You don't want me to put em on the barbie, Make em illegal.
Right after you done huggin your trees.

frankypettolina · 08-08-2009, 12:06 AM

Lots of internet experts this week that is for sure. i wonder how many of them have ever held the leader on a hot blue marlin with half a mil at stake, and tried to calculate whether it was 455 or 505......... When you may get only one gaff shot, and your employer is on the rod and your job on the line.......

Oh wait, a majority of these people doing the criticizing are at their job in some office, wasting their employers money while screwing off on the internet watching the weigh ins.....

Sorry folks, it is a fishing tournament, and some fish are going to die. it seems like it takes an 80 plus pounder to win these things anymore, does that mean we should release the 75 on day one cause it might not hold up all week? It died just as much as the one that fell a few pounds short, and it finished out of the money just the same.

If you don't want to kill a fish, don't enter a kill tourney. If seeing some extra dead ones bothers you so much, don't watch the weigh ins. End of story.

And to answer the original question- I would stick the blue one in a heart beat if it looked close to weight.

Capt-D · 08-08-2009, 01:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frankypettolina

Lots of internet experts this week that is for sure. i wonder how many of them have ever held the leader on a hot blue marlin with half a mil at stake, and tried to calculate whether it was 455 or 505......... When you may get only one gaff shot, and your employer is on the rod and your job on the line.......

Oh wait, a majority of these people doing the criticizing are at their job in some office, wasting their employers money while screwing off on the internet watching the weigh ins.....

Sorry folks, it is a fishing tournament, and some fish are going to die. it seems like it takes an 80 plus pounder to win these things anymore, does that mean we should release the 75 on day one cause it might not hold up all week? It died just as much as the one that fell a few pounds short, and it finished out of the money just the same.

If you don't want to kill a fish, don't enter a kill tourney. If seeing some extra dead ones bothers you so much, don't watch the weigh ins. End of story.

And to answer the original question- I would stick the blue one in a heart beat if it looked close to weight.

Well Said Franky! Congrats to all that got the chance to fish and additional kudos to all who hit the scales, even those that didn't make the money!

PS I would love to see the fool that said the playmate crew were a-holes say that chit dockside!

-D

rabcoman · 08-08-2009, 03:31 AM

Congrats to all that got the chance to bring a fish to the scales. does any body know how hard it is for a charter boat capt. when u have paying pp fishing and they want to take that fish home or to the scales. we have to live to and pay bills bills bills and more f--k bills and then have the pp at the docks y did u have to kill it. do what u have to do to live. be safe and happy.

08-07-2009, 10:30 PM	#15
BigSteads Hide- My Wifes Logged On Join Date: Sep 2006 Posts: 130 Credits: 1,603.8	I think people jump to alot on conclusions about 'under sized' fish way too fast, they made fed. length, and tournament length so...you grease em, all the whites on the board all were withing 69 3/4'' to 73.5'' your talking numbers where only judgement comes into play and it is really easy to sit behind a computer at home and point the finger, when your staring at the fish laying on the deck its a whole different ballgame. Dont give me the bullsht caclulations either on a whitey. Blues, yea...let me haul it on board do all the measurements to the T calc it, and throw it back. Pretty sure it may swim off the first 100 feet. so to me, weigh it, give to charity and people who need something to eat. 19 dead whitey 7?? blues. top 2/3 fish biggest in 29 years? on whites 1st place blue biggest ever. period. Sounds like good numbers to me over the hundreds that were released, +/- 7% of the fish hooked this year were greased. congrats to all who weighed fish, and Longfin Lance on taking 2nd! ps. how about the rest of the leaderboard this year Last edited by BigSteads; 08-07-2009 at 10:43 PM.*

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

08-07-2009, 02:06 PM	#12
Bert Rodgers I think Admin is going to let me have this space Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Phoenix MD Posts: 2,622 Credits: 3,077.9 Home Port: OCMD	Well said JP. Marlinrojo , not so much. Bert

08-07-2009, 06:08 PM	#13
reel fool Sit down Shut up And fish Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Cairns, Australia Posts: 536 Credits: 5,333.0 Boat: Yours Home Port: I move too much Best Catch: 1100 lbs black marlin released Occupation: Deckhand / Captain	You guys poo pooing on killing marlin have obviously never eaten blue marlin...its excellent. Tastes just like bald eagle....and way better than spotted owl.

08-07-2009, 09:35 PM	#14
LongRigger Master Baiter Join Date: Jan 2009 Posts: 48 Credits: 450.4	I prefer tiger jerky with a side of bottlenose dolphin.

08-07-2009, 11:09 PM	#16
Zummie I practice safe fishing Join Date: Jun 2009 Location: Tampa Bay, Fl. Posts: 71 Credits: 385.3 Boat: 28' Pro Kat twin Honda 225's	Come on now, anyone can kill a fish. Club a kitten and throw it on the barbie with a little mango chutney. Now, that's good eating.

08-08-2009, 12:06 AM	#18
frankypettolina killing stuff cause it feels good Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: OCMD Posts: 2,071 Credits: 4,190.1 Boat: Last Call Home Port: Ocean City, MD Best Catch: triple slam in Venezuela 1997 or 31 sails in a day Mexico 98 Occupation: Marine Surveyor and Charterboat Captain	Lots of internet experts this week that is for sure. i wonder how many of them have ever held the leader on a hot blue marlin with half a mil at stake, and tried to calculate whether it was 455 or 505......... When you may get only one gaff shot, and your employer is on the rod and your job on the line....... Oh wait, a majority of these people doing the criticizing are at their job in some office, wasting their employers money while screwing off on the internet watching the weigh ins..... Sorry folks, it is a fishing tournament, and some fish are going to die. it seems like it takes an 80 plus pounder to win these things anymore, does that mean we should release the 75 on day one cause it might not hold up all week? It died just as much as the one that fell a few pounds short, and it finished out of the money just the same. If you don't want to kill a fish, don't enter a kill tourney. If seeing some extra dead ones bothers you so much, don't watch the weigh ins. End of story. And to answer the original question- I would stick the blue one in a heart beat if it looked close to weight.

08-08-2009, 03:31 AM	#20
rabcoman Got fish Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: n.y. Posts: 178 Credits: 1,728.9 Boat: 40' rabco c.c. Home Port: freeport n.y. Best Catch: offshore love Occupation: charter captain	Congrats to all that got the chance to bring a fish to the scales. does any body know how hard it is for a charter boat capt. when u have paying pp fishing and they want to take that fish home or to the scales. we have to live to and pay bills bills bills and more f--k bills and then have the pp at the docks y did u have to kill it. do what u have to do to live. be safe and happy.