What would you Do?

[Squidnation]

I'll give you a hint. Everyone is being rather conventional about this. You need to think out of the box (no pun or hidden hint intended).

[budddavid]

Bluefin
Longfin
Fat Albert
Mahi
Wahoo
Triggerfish

[HOLWACHAGOT]

HOW MANY DO I HAVE RIGHT?
DID YOU BOTTOM FISH OR BAITFISH?


I WOULD HAVE BEEN STUPID ENOUGH TO BREAK OFF THE SMALL ONE IF ANYTHING GOT BROKE OFF INTENTIONALLY

[John Rogers]

That had to be a tough call for the capt.. But it sounds like he did the right thing. Better getting one to the boat then none.



Blue Marlin
white marlin
yellowfin


Bluefin
skippy
wahoo
dolphin
false albacore
bluefish

[Capt-D]

I would play out the 300lbder and circle on the larger one (to gain line) depending on the location of both fish. Working each fish to keep the line on. Eventually landing the smallerone first. Keeping in mind that the odds that we would not land the larger fish!

My Guess:

Wahoo
Mahi
Longfin
BFT
YFT
WM
BM
Mako
Cobia

[Squidnation]

HOW MANY DO I HAVE RIGHT?
DID YOU BOTTOM FISH OR BAITFISH?


I WOULD HAVE BEEN STUPID ENOUGH TO BREAK OFF THE SMALL ONE IF ANYTHING GOT BROKE OFF INTENTIONALLY

You got 3 right. We trolled all day. Sept 5th. I have been reading everyones answers and their are two that no one has mentioned.

[Capt-D]

your missing swords and spearfish

-D

[Dave Sikorski]

I'm guessing one of the missing is in the shark category....Thresher? Hammerhead?

-D

[BTH284]

Well there is always one that shows up in my spread so I am going with the stinky 'cuda
Kingmack
YFT
Blue marlin
White marlin
Sword
Blackfin tuna
wahoo
Dolphin (mahi)
longfin tuna (true albacore)

[Squidnation]

We are down 1 one species that has not been mentioned but no has put together the 9 yet