Carp on the fly - Upstate NY

Trout-N-About · 07-11-2008, 09:49 PM

Capt. Jason Franz
Trout-N-About Charter & Guide Service
http://troutnaboutcharters.com

Hi everyone ! Hope your summer is going well. Thanks for the warm welcome.

Here are some highlights of the carp fishing today on dry flies. Carp are spooky and hard to catch, but we managed to catch a few. Great fun!

DoOver · 09-21-2008, 10:29 PM

Can you eat them? We have them down here in the Pepacton Reservior that I fish. I never thought of targeting them. How do they fight? I always thought they where bottom feeders. My wife tail hooked one. I saw gold and thought it was a record smallie.

Brianb

bigfish4me · 09-22-2008, 09:54 AM

Very nice, what did you get that grass carp to eat? There is a pond with them in it down here and they seriously look like logs....got a few that have to be pushing 50 lbs, but they are super spooky and wont touch corn or dough baits like common carp.

CapeMayRay · 09-22-2008, 12:05 PM

Wow, looks like some fun. I remember catching them on dough baits when I was a kid in the Delaware River. Being interesting hearing how you go about getting them on the fly. Don't know if the same techniques work in tidal waters. Nice Fish!

DoOver · 09-23-2008, 10:57 PM

I think I caught two of these today. I was fishing the Suskie in Oneonta NY during the heat of the day. Water was low slow and dirty. I generally catch smallies in this spot. Both fish hit a #3 gold blue fox. They didn't hit real hard but both fought good. Both fish where about 18" long and thick. They looked kind of like carp but both had fish mouths. They where goldish and had trianglear scales.
Jerry, the bait shop man at Goodyear Lake said it might be an Otsego Lake Bass. After looking again at the first post I say no. I can't beleive carp have fish mouths and take trout lures!!
Brian

09-21-2008, 10:29 PM	#2
DoOver Weeekend Warrior Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Catskill Mountains Of New York Posts: 7 Credits: 1,456.0 Boat: 17 Aqua Sport, Canyon Rigged 14' Duranuatic Row Boat Home Port: Kingston NY Best Catch: Does size really matter? Occupation: Electrical Contractor	Holy Carp Crap, Capt!! Can you eat them? We have them down here in the Pepacton Reservior that I fish. I never thought of targeting them. How do they fight? I always thought they where bottom feeders. My wife tail hooked one. I saw gold and thought it was a record smallie. Brianb

09-23-2008, 10:57 PM	#5
DoOver Weeekend Warrior Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Catskill Mountains Of New York Posts: 7 Credits: 1,456.0 Boat: 17 Aqua Sport, Canyon Rigged 14' Duranuatic Row Boat Home Port: Kingston NY Best Catch: Does size really matter? Occupation: Electrical Contractor	Holy Carp. I think I caught two of these today. I was fishing the Suskie in Oneonta NY during the heat of the day. Water was low slow and dirty. I generally catch smallies in this spot. Both fish hit a #3 gold blue fox. They didn't hit real hard but both fought good. Both fish where about 18" long and thick. They looked kind of like carp but both had fish mouths. They where goldish and had trianglear scales. Jerry, the bait shop man at Goodyear Lake said it might be an Otsego Lake Bass. After looking again at the first post I say no. I can't beleive carp have fish mouths and take trout lures!! Brian

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

09-22-2008, 09:54 AM	#3
bigfish4me I think Admin is going to let me have this space Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: Conshohocken pa Posts: 1,161 Credits: 8,426.1 Boat: 17' mckee craft Home Port: Townsends inlet nj Best Catch: 320# bluefin in jersey waters Occupation: machinist	Very nice, what did you get that grass carp to eat? There is a pond with them in it down here and they seriously look like logs....got a few that have to be pushing 50 lbs, but they are super spooky and wont touch corn or dough baits like common carp.

09-22-2008, 12:05 PM	#4
CapeMayRay I think Admin is going to let me have this space Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Cape May, New Jersey Posts: 1,111 Credits: 2,650.6 Occupation: Charter Capt.	Wow, looks like some fun. I remember catching them on dough baits when I was a kid in the Delaware River. Being interesting hearing how you go about getting them on the fly. Don't know if the same techniques work in tidal waters. Nice Fish!