
Originally Posted by
SeaBiscuit
Been trying to stay out of this one myself, but can't stand it anymore. I am a recreational fisherman and have commercial fished in the past. The folks I know from either side of this have a lot in common. Most importantly both professional commercial fishermen and typical recs share a deep love for the resource and it's environment.
I believe that commercial fishing can be clean, directed and sustainable, but only if left to the professionals. Certain techniques are more destructive and indiscriminate than others and such techniques certainly require ongoing study and regulation. There will never be consensus as to which practices those are and that is exactly why it should be job of scientists (not politicians and lobbyists) to do the studying and regulating.
I am however convinced that the practice of commercial use of any fishery resource by those not professionally employed in that fishery is WRONG. Recreational fishermen should not gill net or shrimp trawl anymore than they should long line or fish trap. Techniques, such as the ones mentioned here are intended to capture the targeted species at numbers much greater than what might be considered a "reasonable" recreational limit and can be indiscriminate, especially in the hands of an unprofessional (rec and commercial alike) fisherman.
Commercial gear must become off limits to recs and NO rec should EVER be allowed to sell ANY amount of our precious natural resource.
Just my opinion.
SeaBiscuit